I wrote and posted this article originally on the Quantified Self blog on November 8, 2010.
This is the second article of a series where I review several self-tracking tools. I will go on a little tangent this week. To make it clear what I look for in different tools, I will discuss the different aspects of self-tracking tools to consider when making a selection. These considerations are based on my own experience tracking myself, feedback from users of tools that I've built, and from my research in human-computer interaction and personal informatics .
First thing to consider is what question about yourself are you trying to answer and would the self-tracking tool collect the right data to answer your question. For example, you might be interested in losing some weight. Your first thought might be to get a pedometer to start tracking your daily step counts. However, your physical activity (or lack thereof) is only one of the factors that might be causing your weight gain; your diet, how busy you are, stress, and other aspects of your lifestyle may also contribute. Determining what information to collect is critical because you will be spending significant time during the next week or two collecting data. You want your collected data to be full of insight. Here are some web pages to help you:
- QS Tool Roundups: Goals , Food , Fitness , Location
- Personal Informatics Tools
The second thing to consider is how you want to collect the data. Data collection is one of the most time-consuming aspects of self-tracking, so you want to pick the tool that works best with your time constraints and comfort level. The following are some of the properties of devices or services relevant to data collection.
- Is the data manually-collected or automatically-collected? For example, your bank account and credit card history are automatically-collected. Mint and Quicken leverage these data and add another level of automation by combining all of your accounts into one interface. On the other hand, there are many many financial tools that require you to manually enter data, such as MoneyBook , GnuCash .
- Do you have to wear or carry a device? This aspect is probably domain-specific. You don't need to wear a device to track your spending, moods, and electricity usage, but tracking physiological data such as physical activity, heart rate, blood sugar level, etc. require wearing devices everyday. Having to wear a device requires considering comfort, visibility, and robustness of the device. To illustrate the differences between devices, I will describe some physical activity tools with varying degrees of wearability:
- Heart rate monitors - These devices provide plenty of specific data about physical exertion, but you have to wear them around your chest, so you probably wouldn't wear them all day. These devices are usually worn by serious athletes while training.
- Bodymedia SenseWear armband - This device also provides plenty of specific data about physical activity. You have to wear the device around your biceps, so it's very noticeable even when wearing a long-sleeve shirt. This is another tool that you won't wear all day long, but would be useful during training times.
- iPod nano - I mentioned this device in my last review . Its small form factor is ideal for tracking your physical activity all day. The device might still be noticeable clipped to your shirt or to your pants pocket, but it's not too bothersome because many people carry their music players with them.
- Fitbit - This is the device that is probably the most inconspicuous of the 4 devices mentioned here. The device is even smaller than the iPod nano and can be easily hidden. Additionally, synching your data online is done automatically just by being near the Fitbit base station.
- Are you prompted to collect data? Most web sites where you manually collect data is voluntary. You visit the site on your own time and manually enter your data. If you want to minimize interruptions in your life, you may want this, but you definitely risk having sparse data. Some services provide alerts to prompt you to record. To illustrate the difference, I will use two mood tracking services: MoodJam and TrackYourHappiness.org . With MoodJam, you have to remember to go to the web site to record your mood. On the other hand, TrackYourHappiness.org sends you an SMS message 3-5 times a day. Since TrackYourHappiness is also a study that requires participation over several weeks, you will need to be patient with the service.
The last thing to consider is how you want to reflect on the data. There are different ways in which you can reflect on your data. The tool can provide visualizations or the tool can be more proactive by sending you alerts with suggestions and tips on what you should do. Here are some questions to ask about this aspect of tools (I will use electricity tracking tools to describe each aspect):
- Does the tool provide the necessary views into your data, so you can keep aware of what's happening with you right now? For example, Kill-A-Watt has a display, so you can immediately see how much electricity an appliance is using.
- Does the tool provide the necessary visualizations to help you explore your data deeply and find insights into your data? Kill-A-Watt does not provide visualizations, but Holmes , the companion tool to Wattson , has visualizations to allow you to look at trends and patterns of your electricity usage over the past 28 days.
- Does the system provide alerts, suggestions, and tips based on your data? In addition to helping you track your energy consumption, WattzOn allows you to compare and discuss your energy consumption with others. The energy consumption tracking is not automated like Wattson, but the community aspect is helpful in getting suggestions and tips on how to reduce energy consumption.
I'm sure there are more things to consider when self-tracking, but this should be a good list to start with when starting your self-tracking regimen. Leave notes in the comments section for other considerations that you think are important.
More information
Bio
Ian Li is a PhD candidate in Human-Computer Interaction Institute at Carnegie Mellon University . His research is on HCI and personal informatics . He is the creator of various self-tracking tools, such as: PersonalInformatics.org , Grafitter , MoodJam , Be Like Ben , and DeliciousDiscovery .
jianbin0903michael kors handbags clearance
ReplyDeleteversace sunglasses on sale
oakley sunglasses
giuseppe zanotti outlet
tory burch outlet online
tory burch shoes
christian louboutin shoes
fred perry polo shirts
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
abercrombie and fitch
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops outlet
cheap jordan shoes
true religion outlet uk
nfl jerseys wholesale
the north face jacket
lacoste pas cher
replica watches
louis vuitton bags
timberland shoes
valentino outlet
ralph lauren uk
christian louboutin outlet
nike roshe run
adidas wings shoes
uggs outlet
polo pas cher
ugg outlet online
ugg outlet
ReplyDeletepolo ralph lauren
canada goose jackets outlet
supra sneakers
discount ugg boots
nike roshe run
ugg boots outlet
timberland outlet
uggs for men
fitflops
2016.11.11chenlixiang
coach outlet
ReplyDeletemulberry purse
coach outlet
nike blazer low
ray ban sunglasses outlet
coach factory outlet
adidas nmd
fit flops
converse shoes
michael kors outlet
20170118caiyan
ralph lauren outlet
ReplyDeletearmani outlet
new balance shoes
eagles jerseys
ugg outlet
packers jerseys
hugo boss
ralph lauren pas cher
colts jerseys
michael kors handbags sale
canada goose jackets
ReplyDeletelouboutin shoes
philipp plein outlet
yeezy shoes
adidas ultra boost
fitflops sale
michael kors canada
new balance outlet
supreme shirts
hermes bag
cc20180511
pandora outlet
ReplyDeletelouboutin outlet
coach outlet
canada goose jackets
pandora outlet store
canada goose jackets
ray ban sunglasses
giuseppe zanotti outlet
christian louboutin uk
coach outlet
20180519wanglili
hogan outlet online
ReplyDeleteyeezy wave runner 700
ray ban sunglasses
100% real jordans for cheap
jordan retro
curry 4
nike air presto
kevin durant shoes
nike shox for women
true religion
20180814 junda
ReplyDeletecoach outlet
christian louboutin shoes
canada goose outlet
ecco shoes
christian louboutin outlet
cheap snapbacks
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet
armani exchange
canada goose jackets
ReplyDeleteشركة تنظيف الامارات
شركة تنظيف دبي شركة نظافة بدبي
شركة تنظيف كنب دبي بالبخار تنظيف كنب دبي بالبخار
شركة غسيل سجاد بدبي غسيل سجاد دبي
شركة تنظيف في ابوظبي شركات تنظيف ابوظبي
شركة تنظيف منازل فى العين شركة تنظيف منازل العين
شركات تنظيف كنب في ابوظبي شركات تنظيف كنب ابوظبي
1movies
ReplyDeletenike lebron 16
ReplyDeleteyeezys
golden goose sneakers
supreme
yeezy
off-white
yeezy boost 350
jordan shoes
hermes birkin
moncler coat